
The steps of Low Library. Courtesy of Ira Cooper (CC’76).
By: Christabelle Sutter, CC’27
Much of the research that undergraduates engage in today occurs within the setting of the university, whether in the form of term papers or senior theses. The environment of a university, especially that of Columbia, provides a setting that is remarkably conducive to initiating, completing, and even publishing research. However, the question of what happens after the completion of research is largely up to the individual researcher.
Commonly, scholars fall into a research mindset fixated on results, without consideration of the impact the research will have on the researcher as a person, not just as someone involved in the academic or professional world. Admittedly, too often I have fallen into the trap of simply moving on to the next assignment after the completion of the one at hand, with the result of missing out on potential personal development. When thinking about the purpose of research, I think it is profitable to not only conduct a consideration of research on the microscale but also on the macroscale of the university itself and its mission. I believe that it is through developing a view that imbues the university with more meaning, founded in an understanding that the university at its core is not a utilitarian construct but one that cares for the individual thinker, that the researcher may likewise find fulfillment in this specific type of labor of research, undertaken in the university setting.
Last summer, I encountered the speeches of John Stuart Mill and John Henry Newman on the topic of the university, two thinkers who form two different and yet somewhat similar schools of thought relating to the telos of the university. Both Newman and Mill defend the importance of the liberal arts and uncover the ways in which wide-ranging study makes the student a better individual and more well-informed citizen.
The thought of the Catholic theologian and cardinal John Henry Newman can recover what is oftentimes lost in today’s culture of research. His 1852 work The Idea of a University illuminates his view of how studying within the university and being a student of the liberal arts is not remotely a utilitarian endeavor. Instead, Newman considers that the purpose of the university rests in the pursuit of knowledge for its own sake, an endeavor that results in the formation of a true ‘gentleman’:
“Liberal Education makes… the gentleman. It is well to be a gentleman, it is well to have a cultivated intellect, a delicate taste, a candid, equitable, dispassionate mind, a noble and courteous bearing in the conduct of life; these are the connatural qualities of a large knowledge; they are the objects of a University.”
Likewise, I think these very qualities can come about through meaningful research and in some sense be the objects of research.
Meanwhile, John Stuart Mill’s thoughts on the university can be found in his “Inaugural Address” delivered to the University of St. Andrews on February 1st, 1867. John Stuart Mill, of course, is featured in the Contemporary Civilization curriculum, with his works On Liberty and The Subjection of Women. As is the case with most authors studied in CC, there is much more to explore within Mill’s collection of works. In one assertive quotation from his address, Mill remarks:
“Whatever [a university] teaches, it should teach as penetrated by a sense of duty; it should present all knowledge as chiefly a means to worthiness of life, given for the double purpose of making each of us practically useful to his fellow-creatures, and of elevating the character of the species itself; exalting and dignifying our nature.”
The way Mill speaks about benefit of university study and its utility to humanity is grounded not simply in the sense of producing research that adds to the “treasure of the thoughts of mankind” (to borrow an analogy from Mill), but also in the understanding that improving oneself and in turn improves society. Thus, bettering oneself and becoming a “gentleman” is not selfish per se, but instead can be considered an act of service to the community.
Regardless of which of the two views you hold to be superior concerning why the individual should be made better through study, both researching for its own sake and researching to become a better individual and contributor to society are conducive to finding fulfillment in research. In this way, research promotes the purpose of a university. With this in mind, how could one not approach research with a gravitas that leads the researcher to contemplate the findings days or weeks after ‘concluding’ the project?